The fingernail test
Run a fingernail across the scratch. If it doesn't catch, polishing will usually clear it. If it catches, the scratch is deeper than polishing can safely remove, because taking off that much glass leaves a wavy surface you can see at an angle. Those phones need reglass.
How to sort a batch before you send it
- Polish: haze, light hairline scratches, marks that only show under bright light.
- Reglass: scratches that catch a fingernail, cracks, chipped corners, deep scuffs from pockets and keys. The display must still work.
- Screen + IC transfer: anything with display damage, like lines, spots or dead touch. See screen replacement.
Don't have time to sort? Send the batch as it is. Each phone gets the right fix, and your IMEI list comes back showing which service each one got.
Why it matters for grading
Auction and marketplace grades turn on the screen. A phone with a clean screen and light housing wear grades much higher than the same phone with a scratched screen. Choosing polish where it's enough, and reglass where it isn't, gets the most phones into the higher grade at the lowest cost per phone.